Sun. Nov 22nd, 2026
Max Pollack – BDJ 342 Package 1
VIDEO TRANSCRIPT: Westcott Theater closure raises concerns for nearby Syracuse businesses

REPORTER MAX POLLACK (:00.22-:16.20): “For nearly 18 years, Westcott Theater brought events and live music to Syracuse. Just this year, it hosted artists such as rapper Fetty Wap and DJ Ian Asher. Now, with its doors closed, people on Westcott Street are reflecting on what the neighborhood is losing.”

SOT 1 MAXWELL HARVEY-SAMPSON (:16.21-:27.12): “It’s a choice to remove a significant cultural marker for the neighborhood, and I think that the other businesses will not have those clients anymore.”

REPORTER MAX POLLACK (:27.19-:43.11): “On Sept. 28, the Syracuse Common Council unanimously voted to revoke the theater’s special use permit, citing safety concerns and alleged violations. The theater’s owner said the venue was being treated unfairly, but the city had already completed its process.”

REPORTER STANDUP MAX POLLACK (:43.12-:57.09): “The vote took place here at Syracuse City Hall. But its effects will reach far beyond these walls, to Westcott Street, where nearby businesses could lose customers who come for a concert and stay for a late-night meal.”

REPORTER MAX POLLACK (:57.29-1:03.23): “Joe Flower, a barista at Recess Coffee, says the closure will change the atmosphere of the neighborhood.”

SOT 2 JOE FLOWER (1:04.07-1:20.06): “I don’t think that people will see the immediate direct consequence of the Westcott Theater closing, but in a few months, in a year, it will look different. It’s little things that end up having a big impact, even if it’s not big on the business end immediately.”

REPORTER MAX POLLACK (1:21.04-1:36.02): “While the vote closed the doors to Westcott Theater, business owners are left watching their own doors. Before closing, the theater left one message to the public: ‘If you can’t say something nice, don’t say nothing at all.’ In Syracuse, for N-C-C News, I’m Max Pollack.”

Outside Westcott Theater in Syracuse with its doors closed and branding gone.
Westcott Theater in Syracuse is closed after the Syracuse Common Council voted to revoke its special use permit. © Max Pollack

SYRACUSE, N.Y. — Westcott Theater has closed its doors after the Syracuse Common Council voted unanimously to revoke its special use permit, leaving the neighborhood wondering how Westcott Street will change.

The council voted Sept. 28 at City Hall after an 18-page city report cited safety concerns and alleged violations at the venue, including an Aug. 1 double stabbing that police say happened inside the theater. The theater’s owner, Daniel Mastronardi, has said the business was treated unfairly. City officials had already completed their review process.

During its nearly 18 years, the theater hosted concerts and large gatherings that brought the community together. This year, the venue hosted performers including rapper Fetty Wap and DJ Ian Asher. The effects of the council’s decision could reach beyond Westcott Theater to Westcott Street, where less foot traffic for events could mean fewer customers for surrounding businesses.

Maxwell Harvey-Sampson, a Syracuse resident, said the impact goes deeper than lost business. He pointed to what the theater meant to the neighborhood beyond its events.

“It’s a choice to remove a significant cultural marker for the neighborhood and I think that the other businesses will not have those clients anymore,” Harvey-Sampson said.

Joe Flower, a barista at nearby Recess Coffee, said the atmosphere of the neighborhood will change without the theater, but it may take time to notice.

“I don’t think people will see the immediate direct consequence of the Westcott Theater closing, but in a few months, in a year, it will look different,” Flower said. “It’s the little things that end up having a big impact even if it’s not big on the business end immediately.”

While Westcott Theater is closed, the revocation does not mean the building will sit vacant forever. Common Council President Rita Paniagua said the council wants a theater where everyone feels safe. City officials have said a future applicant could pursue a new special use permit that would allow for entertainment at the theater.

For Westcott Street, the future depends on who applies for a new permit and whether the theater will ever reopen. Until that is decided, neighbors and businesses are left waiting.