
Syracuse, N.Y. (NCC News) —
VIDEO TRANSCIPT
REEL 1:
With the new potential redesign to the Christopher Columbus statue in downtown Syracuse in Columbus Circle, locals like Scott Jakoy say this could bring a new energy to the city of Syracuse and the Central New York community as a whole, and attract more people to the downtown area.
I’ve seen some of the designs. They look lovely. I think that it would bring a new energy here, and to an area that is beautiful but underutilized. So, I would love to see, you know, what they could bring.
Locals say there are no potential negatives to bringing a new structure to Columbus Circle in downtown Syracuse.
I can only see the positives of sort of bringing that new energy into the circle.
Bringing a new structure here will only bring up the population, and it can only go up from here. For NCC News, I’m Jack Nevins.
REEL 2:
Here in downtown Syracuse in Columbus Circle, the city pushes to get rid of this Christopher Columbus statue and push for a redesign.
Local Syracuse lawyer Shawn Chase, who works in the courthouse just behind the statue, says he sees this statue every day and feels there is no need to get rid of this statue.
I am of the opinion that a statue being moved or changed is a vast waste of taxpayers’ resources.
The Onondaga Historical Association announced three new redesigns last Tuesday night. These redesigns include Memory Park, Living Circles, and the Unity Plus Heritage Park. For NCC News, I’m Jack Nevins.
Scott Jackoway looks at Columbus Circle and sees a space that isn’t living up to its potential. Shaun Chase walks past it every day on his way to work and sees a monument that should stay right where it is.
The two Syracuse residents are on opposite sides of a debate that has surrounded the Christopher Columbus statue downtown for six years. It flared up again this month when the Onondaga Historical Association revealed three finalist designs for the site’s future.
On Nov. 10, the OHA unveiled three proposals to reimagine the site as Heritage Park. They are titled “Memory Park,” “Living Circles” and “Unity Circle + Heritage Walk.” All three leave out the Christopher Columbus statue.
The OHA’s Full Circle Design Competition covers Columbus Circle, the Columbus monument and the vacant lot across East Onondaga Street that once housed the Powelson Business Institute. The goal is a new civic and public art space that recognizes the many cultures and histories tied to the site.
“I’ve seen some of the designs. They look lovely,” Jackoway said. “I think that it would bring a new energy here and to an area that is beautiful but underutilized.”
Jackoway said he sees no downside to putting a new structure in the circle and believes it would draw more people downtown.
“I can only see the positives of sort of bringing that new energy in to the circle,” he said.
Chase disagrees. He is a Syracuse lawyer who works in the courthouse just behind the statue, and he sees it every day. He doesn’t see a reason to change it.
“I have the opinion that a statue being moved or changed is a vast waste of taxpayer resources,” Chase said.
The monument was installed in 1934 after members of Syracuse’s Italian American community raised money for it. Supporters see it as a tribute to the immigrant families who helped build the city. Others see Columbus as a symbol of colonization and historical oppression.
The fight over the statue began in October 2020, when then-Mayor Ben Walsh announced it would come down in favor of a cultural heritage site honoring both Italian Americans and Native Americans. The Columbus Monument Corporation sued to stop him. In March 2022, state Supreme Court Justice Gerard Neri ruled that the statue should stay, but an appellate court reversed that ruling in July 2023.
The OHA says it takes no position on whether the statue should stay or go and that designers could submit proposals either way. It also says picking a winning design does not authorize construction or decide the monument’s fate.
The Columbus Monument Corporation isn’t convinced. The group alleges the competition was set up with the goal of removing the statue and plans to file an Article 78 proceeding seeking the OHA’s records on how the competition was run.
For now, the statue stays in place. The designs will be on display at the Onondaga Historical Association through Nov. 24, and residents can submit feedback there. A final decision is expected in December.
